APT Reveals How Grain Boundary Segregation Varies Across Length Scales

Grain boundary segregation is often reported as an average composition. Look more closely, however, and that average can hide substantial chemical variation across the interface. This raises a practical question for atom probe tomography: how much grain boundary area must be analyzed before the measured composition is truly representative?

Grain Boundary Segregation

Jacob B. Mack and Christopher A. Schuh explored that question in nanocrystalline Ni-2.5Pd by comparing APT measurements with atomistic simulations. They tracked segregation from small interfacial patches to entire boundaries and tested the methods used to extract those measurements.

 

The results point to an important distinction. In this system, palladium concentration varied far more within the same random boundary than it did from one measured boundary to another. The area included in the analysis therefore mattered as much as the boundaries selected.

 

“Why APT? The problem was inherently spatial. APT provided three-dimensional atomic positions and chemical identities across large analysis volumes. This allowed the researchers to locate boundaries, measure local interfacial excess, map palladium across thousands of square nanometers, and see how the sampled area changed the result.” 

Following Palladium Across the Boundary

The experimental material was nanocrystalline Ni-2.5Pd powder equilibrated at 600 °C, with an average grain size of 110 nm. Researchers analyzed APT specimens using a CAMECA LEAP 5000 XS at the Northwestern University Center for Atom Probe Tomography (NUCAPT). Typical runs collected more than 10 million ions, and a total of eight grain boundaries were captured.

 

The boundaries became visible through an increased apparent density of palladium atoms, reflecting both chemical segregation and local magnification effects. The researchers traced each oriented boundary through successive slices, constructed a three-dimensional mesh, and assigned atoms to equal-area trajectories normal to the interface.

 

Ladder diagrams then provided the Gibbsian interfacial excess for each part of the mesh, showing how palladium segregation changed across the boundary.

 

The analysis workflow is shown in Figure 1: Overview of extracting local grain boundary concentrations from Atom Probe Tomography (a-d) and Atomistic Simulation (e-h) datasets. In order; (a,e) raw data, highlighting positions of solute atoms, from Atom Probe and Atomistics, (b,f) Ellipsoidal binning to label the grain boundary, (c,g) 3D mesh created from labeled points, (d,h) atom assignments for each mesh element, leading to the creation of ladder diagrams.Overview of extracting local grain boundary concentrations from Atom Probe Tomography (a-d) and Atomistic Simulation (e-h) datasets. In order; (a,e) raw data, highlighting positions of solute atoms, from Atom Probe and Atomistics, (b,f) Ellipsoidal binning to label the grain boundary, (c,g) 3D mesh created from labeled points, (d,h) atom assignments for each mesh element, leading to the creation of ladder diagrams.

Analysis workflow
Fig 1

A Single Average Hides Wide Local Variation

At a patch size of about 4 nm², the APT maps showed local palladium concentrations ranging from 0 to 30 at.% within one boundary. That boundary averaged 9.8 at.%, but many smaller regions departed sharply from the mean. The variation remained apparent even at 100 nm², where local values differed from the boundary average by approximately ±4 at.%.

 

Measurement uncertainty could not account for the full spread. At 4 nm², the estimated measurement standard deviation was 2 at.%, compared with an observed standard deviation of 5.2 at.% across the combined dataset. The range narrowed as more of the interface was included, approaching a stable boundary average.

 

The relationship between sampled area and measured concentration is shown in Figure 2.

Analysis workflow
Fig 2

Across eight boundaries covering 14,000 nm², the average compositions clustered at 9.3 ± 2 at.%, with a standard deviation of 1.2 at.%. Their effective segregation energies were within ±3 kJ/mol of the -10 kJ/mol average. The largest differences occurred locally within these interfaces, not between them.

 

Enough Area Matters More Than More Boundaries

Some detailed APT datasets come from nanocrystalline materials in which an individual boundary may cover only about 100 nm². In the boundary examined here, an area of that size was not necessarily representative of the full interface.

 

The authors found that measuring the average concentration of an individual random Ni-Pd boundary required an interfacial area on the order of 1,000 nm². Once they included enough area, the data converged toward a more robust value.

 

The same principle carried over to the polycrystalline average. For this particular system, the determining factor was not simply the number of crystallographically different boundaries. A handful of random boundaries could provide the average, provided that they represented enough total interfacial area.

 

Testing the APT Measurements Against Known Boundaries

The simulations identified exactly which atoms belonged to a grain boundary, allowing the researchers to test the APT analysis procedure against known structural information.

The mesh located from chemical fluctuations closely followed the structurally identified boundary, agreeing to within 0.25 nm normal to the boundary plane. In a dilute Monte Carlo configuration, the ladder-diagram fitting error was 2.6%, equivalent to ±2 atoms. This independently validated the method applied to the APT measurements.

 

The simulations then added site-level context to the concentration maps. Individual simulated boundaries contained much of the segregation-energy spectrum found across the full polycrystal. Although differences between boundaries remained, they were modest compared with the spread of more than 100 kJ/mol among individual sites.

 

They also reproduced the dependence on sampling area. At the smallest areas, calculated concentrations could differ from the true polycrystalline average by ±5 at.%. Grouping boundaries to provide roughly 300 nm² brought the error to within 1 at.% of that average.

 

What Sampling Scale Changes

The comparison also places an important limit on how to interpret local segregation distributions. At small sampling sizes, the measured distribution of effective segregation energies reflects both statistical sampling and correlations in site-wise behavior. Because each local measurement averages multiple atomic sites, it cannot be treated as a direct measurement of the underlying site-wise energy spectrum.

APT showed where palladium accumulated, how strongly its concentration varied across individual interfaces, and how the reported average changed as the analysis area grew. The simulations validated the measurement framework and helped explain the broadening of local distributions.

For researchers using APT to characterize grain boundary segregation, the study demonstrates the value of combining high spatial resolution with large analysis volumes. The total interfacial area included in the measurement can determine whether the result describes a local patch or represents the boundary as a whole.

 

 

Jacob Mack
About Jacob Mack

Jacob Mack is currently a Ph.D. student in the Department of Materials Science and Engineering (DMSE) at Massachusetts Institute of Technology. His research is focused on the chemistry of grain boundaries in metallic alloys, and how it can be manipulated to alter the functional properties of polycrystalline materials. This work spans a range of techniques, including Atom Probe Tomography (APT), TEM, X-ray Diffraction, and atomistic simulations.

Jacob Mack
About Christopher Schuh

Christopher Schuh is the Dean of the Robert R. McCormick School of Engineering at Northwestern University, and holds the title of John G. Searle Professor of Materials Science and Engineering. His research is broadly focused on structural materials including metals and ceramics. Dean Schuh has worked on the topic of grain boundaries and nanocrystalline structures for over twenty years, including the commercialization of various nanocrystalline alloys.

Instrument Notes

This study was performed using a CAMECA LEAP 5000 XS. The CAMECA LEAP 6000 XR is the latest generation of CAMECA’s atom probe platform, designed for three-dimensional compositional analysis at the nanoscale. It combines deep-UV laser pulsing with CAMECA’s proven local electrode design and introduces synchronous voltage and laser pulsing to reduce spectral background, increase sensitivity, and simplify peak identification. These capabilities make the LEAP 6000 XR well suited to studying grain boundary segregation, nanoscale precipitates, interfaces, dopant distributions, and other compositionally complex features in advanced materials.

 

For More Information

Read the scientific article: Mack, J.B., and Schuh, C.A. Spatial distributions of grain boundary segregation - A combined atom probe and atomistic simulation study. Acta Materialia 315 (2026) 122398. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2026.122398

 

 

Illustration of a girl taking CAMECA e-learning training programs

Learn from Experts

We offer training for all instruments and experience levels, available online or at your lab. CAMECA accelerates your learning curve!